NYC Teaching Fellows logo

NYC Teaching Fellows General Intern Interview Questions
& Process

Real candidates share what happened, how many rounds they had,
and how the experience turned out.

Based on 5 interview experiences · FREE TO READ

2.6 Rounds average
Average Typical difficulty
60% Positive experience

Candidate interview experiences

First-hand accounts from people who interviewed at NYC Teaching Fellows.

Showing 3 of 5
NYC Teaching Fellows logo
NYC Teaching Fellows

Fellow

Other · a year ago

Entry Difficult Negative experience No offer 3 rounds
Interview process
Recruiter call Phone screen Technical screen
Interview formats
Behavioral Technical Presentation

The point of the first interview, at least, is just to weed out people based on things that don't really matter for being a good teacher. And even though this is a fellowship for PROFESSIONALS, not teachers, they ask stuff you'd expect a teacher or someone in education to know. It's one thing to see if someone knows about learning or has trained people before, but it's another to quiz people with no teaching background on how to manage a classroom, deal with student behavior, or use specific teaching methods. It feels like you might as well apply to be a licensed teacher. It's a total waste of time to interview for a teacher development program and then get asked about the nuts and bolts of teaching, only to be rejected for not knowing. The first interview should be more about potential, how someone learns, logical thinking, memory, handling stress and conflicts, emotional intelligence, and understanding how to work with diverse groups, not the mechanics of teaching.

Confirmed questions1 question
  • You observe a male student disengaged and staring off during your lesson. When called upon, he can't answer or recall the information just presented, and another student laughs. The disengagement persists. What would you do to handle this student's lack of engagement and what might be the causes for his behavior?
NYC Teaching Fellows logo
NYC Teaching Fellows

Fellow

Other · more than a year ago

Entry Average Positive experience No offer 3 rounds
Interview process
Recruiter call Phone screen Presentation
Interview formats
Behavioral Presentation

First there was an online assessment asking about your background and experience. Then, a 25-minute phone interview where they presented a scenario. Finally, an in-person teaching demonstration that lasted about 3 hours. Don't stress about the teaching part, just follow the online instructions and be yourself. It's a really competitive program, so try not to take it personally if you don't get selected. It was fun meeting other people who were also interested in becoming fellows.

Confirmed questions1 question
  • What is your motivation for becoming a teacher
NYC Teaching Fellows logo
NYC Teaching Fellows

Fellow

Other · more than a year ago

Entry Average Positive experience Decline offer 4 rounds
Interview process
Take home Group Panel Presentation Background check
Interview formats
Technical Presentation Case Behavioral

The application process had three parts. First, you submit an online application, which includes essays answering questions about your views on education and why you want to participate. If you pass that, you move on to a group interview. This interview starts with a math and teaching strategies test. Then, you're split into groups to give a 5-minute teaching presentation. After that, your group works on a case study, and finally, there's an individual interview.

Confirmed questions2 questions
  • In the individual interview, how could you have improved your teaching exercise or added to the group exercise?
  • You don't have much time to reflect, so this can be difficult.

NYC Teaching Fellows General Intern Interview Questions

Quoted word for word from NYC Teaching Fellows interview reports.

You observe a male student disengaged and staring off during your lesson. When called upon, he can't answer or recall the information just presented, and another student laughs. The disengagement persists. What would you do to handle this student's lack of engagement and what might be the causes for his behavior?

Read reports

Based on the feedback, how would you make your demo lesson better?

Read reports

In the individual interview, how could you have improved your teaching exercise or added to the group exercise?

Read report

Formats, difficulty and experience

Across all 5 NYC Teaching Fellows interview reports.

Interview formats

Presentation 35.7%
Behavioral 21.4%
Technical 21.4%
Group 7.1%
Other 7.1%

Interview difficulty

Easy 0%
Average 80%
Difficult 20%

Candidate experience

Negative 20%
Positive 60%
Neutral 20%